Why Women Are Underrepresented in Leadership Positions?

Written by Dimitra ~ Category: Food for Thought ~ Read Time: 5 min.

Throughout history, women have shattered glass ceilings and defied limitations. Their contributions across every field are indisputable, from pioneering scientists to bold entrepreneurs. Today, women represent a powerful force in the global workforce, achieving educational milestones and demonstrating exceptional leadership qualities.

However, despite significant progress in education and qualifications, along with the Gender Equal Compensation, a persistent barrier remains: women are still considerably underrepresented in leadership positions across many industries. This lack of parity not only represents a missed opportunity to leverage the full potential of talent but also hinders company growth and innovation.

Facts and Figures: The Gender Leadership Gap

The underrepresentation of women in leadership positions is a global phenomenon with significant consequences, and the data paints a clear picture of this ongoing disparity:

The 2023 Women in the Workplace Report, conducted by McKinsey and LeanIn, showed that women now occupy the highest level of C-suite representation in history, at 28%.

Women in leadership positions

Source: Research Gate

This gap widens at higher levels, with men significantly outnumbering women in C-suite roles.

In the US, for instance, women CEOs make up a mere 10.4% of Fortune 500 companies.

According to the World Economic Forum, labor force participation parity is highest in North America (84%), followed by Europe (82%), East Asia, and the Pacific (80%).

The International Labour Organization (ILO) reports that women comprise over 40% of the global workforce. This signifies a growing presence of women contributing across various industries and sectors, but only 38% of manager positions globally are occupied by women. This gap widens dramatically at higher levels.

Europe boasts the highest regional gender parity at 76.3%. One-third of European countries rank in the top 20 for overall gender equality. However, women remain underrepresented in leadership roles, particularly on corporate boards and high-level management.

East Asia and the Pacific have the fifth-highest regional score, showing 68.8% parity. Progress varies significantly: New Zealand leads the region, but South Asia lags far behind. Compared to Europe, women hold a smaller share of leadership positions, especially in politics.

It's important to note that the gender leadership gap varies across regions. While some countries have made significant strides towards gender parity in leadership, others continue to lag behind.

Understanding the Barriers

There are several factors that contribute to women's underrepresentation in leadership, and they all sum up in biases.

Unconscious Bias

One of the most significant obstacles women face on their path to leadership is unconscious bias. Unconscious bias is implicit stereotypes and assumptions that unconsciously influence our thoughts and behaviors. It can lead women to underestimate their abilities compared to men, holding them back from applying for leadership roles or advocating for themselves during promotions.

In the context of leadership, unconscious bias can manifest in several ways:

Perception of Leadership Traits

Traditional leadership stereotypes often associate decisiveness, assertiveness, and risk-taking with effective leadership. These qualities are frequently (and unconsciously) attributed more readily to men. Women exhibiting these traits might be perceived as aggressive or bossy, hindering their leadership potential.

The "Motherhood Penalty"

Unconscious bias can penalize women for their maternal roles. The motherhood penalty describes how mothers suffer severe compensation and hiring disadvantages in the workplace. They might be seen as less dedicated or reliable due to potential childcare commitments, even if they are demonstrably high performers, making them less committed leaders. This stereotype ignores the fact that many men also value work-life balance, and many women are perfectly capable of excelling in both areas.

The "Likability Trap"

Women leaders are often held to a higher standard of likability compared to their male counterparts. They might face pressure to conform to a more agreeable or passive leadership style, which can undermine their perceived authority. For example, a woman who makes a tough decision or delivers critical feedback might be seen as harsh or demanding, while a man exhibiting the same behavior might be seen as decisive and strong. This double standard creates a challenging situation for women leaders as they navigate the need to be assertive while maintaining a sense of approachability.

women in leadership

Source: LinkedIn Economic Graph

Confirmation Bias

When evaluating candidates, decision-makers might unconsciously focus on information that confirms pre-existing biases. For example, if a hiring manager assumes women are less suited for technical roles, they might subconsciously downplay a female candidate's technical skills while focusing more on her soft skills. Also, if leadership is seen as a masculine field, interviewers might unconsciously be more likely to see strong leadership qualities in male candidates.

The danger of unconscious bias lies in its subtlety. These biases operate outside our conscious awareness, making them particularly difficult to identify and address

Work-Life Balance Challenges

Women often shoulder a more significant burden of domestic responsibilities, making it harder to navigate the demands of leadership roles that often require long hours and extensive travel.

Even today, women often take on a larger share of household chores, childcare, and eldercare duties than men. This double burden of paid work and unpaid domestic labor creates a significant time crunch, making it difficult for women leaders to maintain the long hours and extensive travel often associated with top positions.

Why Diverse Leadership Leads to Success

While the underrepresentation of women in leadership is a pressing issue, there's a compelling reason to strive for gender parity at the top: companies with strong female leadership demonstrably outperform those without. Studies by McKinsey & Company, such as "Diversity Wins: How Inclusion Matters," have shown a clear correlation between gender diversity in leadership and positive business outcomes. Why?

Diverse Perspectives

Women leaders bring a unique set of experiences and viewpoints to the table. This diversity of thought fosters more creative problem-solving and innovation. When faced with challenges, a leadership team with a broader range of perspectives is better equipped to consider different approaches and arrive at more effective solutions.

Stronger Talent Pool

By breaking barriers for women in leadership, companies tap into a vastly larger pool of qualified talent. This allows them to identify and promote the best person for the job, regardless of gender, leading to a more robust overall leadership team.

Improved Decision-Making

Inclusive leadership that leverages diverse perspectives can lead to more informed and well-rounded decision-making. When a broader range of voices are heard and considered, decision-makers are less likely to fall prey to groupthink or overlook potential blind spots.

Enhanced Reputation and Branding

Companies that champion gender diversity in leadership project a progressive and inclusive image. This can attract top talent, improve customer loyalty, and enhance the company's reputation in the marketplace.

Role Models and Mentorship

The presence of successful women leaders creates positive role models for future generations, inspiring and encouraging more women to pursue leadership aspirations. Additionally, women leaders can mentor and sponsor other women, fostering a culture of support and advancement within the organization.

Bridging the Gender Leadership Gap is not easy; we have much to work on. However, when businesses take more decisive initiatives and create a more welcoming and inclusive environment for women, we will be one step closer to more female leaders.

It took 3 coffees to write this article.


About the author

Dimitra

She worked in corporate, then embraced the freelancer dream and built two successful businesses. In the meantime, she learned five foreign languages, and now she spends her time meeting with clients and writing about whatever life brings. Just a suggestion: don’t ask her about languages; she will never stop talking.

LinkedIn Instagram Facebook
Search